Tuesday, September 7, 2010

Ben Roethlisberger and the Steelers got off Easy


You can thank my never-ending curiosity about certain topics, especially this one, as well as The Ghost of Michael Tillery’s Past, for this post coming to life. Last week, Ben Roethlisberger had his initial four-to-six-game suspension settled at four, thanks to a ruling by Roger Goodell. Initially, there wasn’t much surprise from me, or anyone, but that was for reasons that were on the surface. Sure, there were some people asking questions, and some might have made a spark about it, but there was no raging inferno, no riots in the streets, no hell-raising; absolutely nothing.

Granted, I've always been a fan of The Motorcycle Rider as a quarterback, but it’s impossible for me to look at the man in the same light, after he’s been accused not once, but twice, of sexual assault in the past 12 months. Ladies and gentlemen, that’s twice in one year. Anyway, the point of this post is to look at exactly why the man and his team, in my opinion, got off easy.

No Charges were Filed: this is the easiest one to decipher. If The Court of Public Opinion ruled the land, there’s no telling what Roethlisberger would be charged with, but the bottom line is the man was never charged with a crime.

He Plays for a World-Class Organization: I’m willing to go out on a limb and say that if you play for the Steelers, Cowboys, or the Patriots, you can get away with things that players on a majority of other teams simply cannot afford to. Name recognition, team success, championship lore, visible ownership, and a loyal fan base can all be tied into the fact that Ben Roethlisberger is in an ideal situation. The Pittsburgh Steelers are arguably the most respected organization in all of football. They’ve also won the most Super Bowls, and the Rooney family has been a fixture of the team since its genesis. Sure, Steelers Legend, The Great Terry Bradshaw, had the guts to say the man should have to serve the entire six-game suspension, but when the Rooney family didn’t echo similar sentiments, it made Goodell’s decision much easier.

The Lack of a Widespread and Visible Outcry from Women: For every woman I know who can’t stand Big Ben, there are two that were able to "look the other way" at what he did. There are more who know what the man did was wrong, but it won’t affect them cheering for the Steelers, and honestly, that’s their prerogative. Still, at least when it has been with other crimes, folks rallied behind a similar cause, a la, people calling for Michael Vick’s head when he was fighting dogs, or people rallying behind victims of drunk driving, when Donte’ Stallworth had his incident a while back. Why should Goodell rock the boat, if one of the biggest demographics for the league, which happen to be women, isn’t pressuring him to?

Women make up 46% of NFL merchandise sales and one-third of their television viewing audience, yet they didn't use their influence to rage against the machine against Roethlisberger for his foolishness. The main victims of his dastardly deeds are women, but there were no wide-spread demonstrations, and nothing that would indicate that Roethlisberger had anything to worry about from the demographic that has been affected the most. Once again, it made Goodell’s decision to reduce his suspension that much easier to make. I’m convinced that had women come together and let Goodell know that they were uncomfortable and intolerant of what Roethlisberger did, there would have been more incentive to uphold his initial ruling.

The Race Card: This is more due to the coverage, or lack thereof, of what the man has done. It blows my mind that accusations of this magnitude are swept under the rug by national media. Sure, the man was never charged, but it’s never stopped the media before from going after an athlete before they were charged with anything. Hell, the lack of coverage with this entire thing can lead someone to believe the whole ordeal is a figment of one’s imagination.

In my opinion, Goodell should have kept the suspension at six games. Had The Commissioner initially had it at two games, I still would have rather him kept it at his original ruling. Yes, strides have been made by The Motorcycle Rider to change his ways, but it’s obvious the team, themselves, do not hold Roethlisberger in the same light as they have in the past, as evident by him not being a team captain this season. Some people think it’s a non-issue, but when your own teammates do not vote for you to be a captain, a man who is a top-five quarterback in the league, and someone who has TWO Super Bowl rings in his six-year career, that’s more than telling to me. The man got off easy, his team got off easy, and even Goodell got off easy, but looking at it in this light, its obvious this was how it was destined to go.

Be easy.
-K. Masenda
www.edthesportsfan.com
P.S. As a reminder, checkout the livest sports talk (and hopefully on the radio soon) show around, "The Unsportsmanlike Conduct Show" as we are live Wednesday's at 9pm Eastern at http://www.blogtalkradio.com/edthesportsfan! Download our podcasts if you missed the live show as well!

Comments

10 Responses to "Ben Roethlisberger and the Steelers got off Easy"
  1. Keith said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 6:04:00 AM

    I was surprised too that the national organization for women (NOW) wasn't up in arms like PETA was against Vick. And I don't like playing the race card, but time after time it's been proven to be the right card to play.

    On the other hand, the man was never arrested, let alone charged w/ a crime. I went back and forth w/ this when it first happened. I understand why Goodell suspended Ben, but at the same time, I find it difficult to be in favor of suspending a guy who hasn't even been arrested for 6 games on his first offense, especially when there's a presumption of innocence in this country (according to the law, that is). The omnipotent Judge Goodell took care of that though. He found Ben guilty and sentenced him to a 6 game suspension. I thought it should've been more like 2 games. Ben just accepted it b/c it would've been bad PR to fight the suspension.

    But yes, he got off easy for the most part. He still has his freedom, his job, and his money. However, there has been irreparable damage done to his reputation in the eyes of a lot of people, including his teammates. Will he ever get that back? I don't know. Maybe that's his ultimate punishment.

  2. dnmppolitico said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 9:07:00 AM

    Glad that ETSF is bringing some attention to this issue...

    1. Welcome to the United States where money will get you off of just about anything...soooo much for justice for all.

    2. NOW & PETA are two different organizations with two different types of strategies for action.

    3. I have to say that I agree with Kenny and the race card. It seems like when players of color get into some trouble its all over the news...not so much with white players. The only thing that seems neutral is when pro players get divorced which beyond gossip blogs/mags and VH1 second rate reality shows get no coverage.

    4. As far as a women's movement outcry, I have to say that they have their hands full with Sarah Palin, her grizzly bears and the 2010 election season; but this situation does show that the women's movement's effectiveness is almost non-existent these days.

  3. MsB, Ph.D. said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 11:09:00 AM

    "The women's movement's effectiveness is almost non-existent these days."
    I'd have to disagree with you on that. It has its serious issues, just like any other major interest group. The differences between the interests of many feminists groups and, say black feminists, is still there, among other things. However, I wouldn't say the entire movement is non-existent.

    As to why groups have been silent? That's a good question. I believe the media plays a significant role in this as well. Ben hasn't gotten even an ounce of the attention that Tiger received, and from most reports, the media has portrayed both women as being suspect (which tends to happen, unfortunately). And, of course, race plays an issue.

    It would be interesting to see a breakdown by demographic and attitudes/beliefs of female NFL fans.

    Honestly, we can debate all day as to whether he's guilty or not. I'll leave my opinion out of it. But, as Kenny stated, he wasn't charged. Bottom line.

    On the one hand, I feel you on the changing of the ruling. Once you start changing suspensions, you open up a Pandora's box for all other cases. On the other hand, I also agree with Keith. If he starts handing out these types of suspensions for those who haven't been convicted (regardless of whether we believe they are guilty), then that just gets sticky...and the percentage of suspended folks would (should) increase.

  4. Anonymous said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 11:18:00 AM

    First - maybe most women didn't "rage" against Ben, because they saw the alleged "victims" were what they really were, a gold digger and a drunk sorority slut, and understood that Ben didn't really do anything wrong? I know that's how I looked at all of this.

    Second - the media swept this story under the rug and didn't cover it? Are you serious? You have to have been living in a cave since March because this story was all over the place and mostly the media vilified Ben.

    Third - why don't you question why James Harrison isn't a team captain again this year? do the Steelers hold him in the same regard as they used to? And, why wasn't Troy made a captain in his place? Is he not held in high regard?

  5. Kenny said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 11:40:00 AM

    @ Anonymous

    Point #1: The same way you can label the women, people could easily label Roethlisberger as an athlete that thinks he can get away with anything, because he's an athlete; that's not how I feel, personally, but it's easy for folks to see it that way, considering the act and the parties involved.

    Point #2: In relation to when Kobe was accused of sexual assault, or when Eldrick Woods cheated on his wife, it would be disingenous to suggest the Roethlisberger incidents have been covered with as much fervor, enthusiasm, or relentlessness as the former.

    Point #3: Great question on Harrison and Troy. My response to that is that both of them, as great as they are at their position, don't compare to a franchise QB. Ben R. is top-five at the position, and when you're in that position, you're about as automatic a captain as can be, and when his own team didn't vote for him, it just says something to me.

  6. Reverend Paul Revere said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 12:44:00 PM

    I think this one's tough because he was never charged with a crime. It's not as black and white as some of the other issues. However, I agree with you that Goodell should have just stayed with hit initial ruling, no matter what that ruling was.

  7. ShirleyHuangESQ said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 4:12:00 PM

    LOL at y'all finding a picture of Goodell giving Big Ben the thumbs up!

  8. Joe said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 7:44:00 PM

    I have to agree with Keith and Trica on this one. I am also concerned about the lack of communication between the Commissioner and other team owners.

    Ben was wrong and Ben was never convicted however, there shouldn't have been a game limit on the original suspension anyways and this would have never been an issue. He should have been suspended indefinitely until the case had been resolved. Then after the resolution the suspension should have been stated 4 - 6 games pending good behavior. Then owners will have a sense of constancy amongst suspension in the league.

    You can't put all suspension in the same category but there has to be a formula for determining what the possible punishments for stupidity will be. You can come up with something for drugs but you can't for stupidity. This has to be addressed.

  9. Reggie said...
    Tuesday, September 07, 2010 8:49:00 PM

    I've been a Steelers fan since I was a little boy. I'm old enough to remember Terry Bradshaw as a reasonably young quarterback.

    Plain and simple, Ben Roethlisberger is a scumbag. Regardless, I will ALWAYS be a Steelers fan. The up side of this is that we are giving our quarterback of the future an opportunity to get more experience playing on a regular basis. Hopefully he'll flourish in this role. Regardless Ben won't be traded way.....not unless Dennis Dixon surprises the living hell outta everybody to a level that seems out of reach right now.

    I wish him the best. Ben is a great quarterback, he's just not a great man. As the father of a college sophomore daughter, I think that he should be thrown outta the league if he ever does anything remotely close to what he's been accused of again.

  10. Anonymous said...
    Wednesday, September 08, 2010 9:48:00 AM

    @ Reggie

    Please, please tell me that you have lectured your college sophomore daughter on how it is NOT okay to get drunk underage in a bar, wear a sexually explicit name tag and follow a man she doesn't really know around all night.

Post a Comment

Drop a line folks...no anonymous commenters!

Related Posts with Thumbnails
 

Copyright 2009 All Rights Reserved Revolution Two Church theme by Brian Gardner | Blogger template converted & enhanced by eBlog Templates